Internet Dating, Finding Love and Probability Theory
Life and love: How to connect--and, get this: Write it! How to get started
I once had a Pilates teacher—39, drop-dead gorgeous, long, thin, athletic ballerina body, delicate hands and feet—got dumped by her live-in boyfriend (fours years live-in!). While you can pay a matchmaking service to find your match, she dabbled on a free site.
She got 20 to 30 possible “doors” to open a day, meaning men who wanted to chat, wanted to date, who opened with bad lines like this one: “You’re so cute. Wanna have sex?”
Or the guy who asked her if she was adventurous. She said, “What do you mean?" He replied, “Have sex while a third person watches.”
Then Angel appeared. Yes, that's his real name and, even better, he’s an Air Force pilot. He asked for exclusivity after one date: a glass of wine downtown, not even dinner, and a smooch at her door.
He stopped texting and calling after he saw she was still online.
Now Pilates could have given up at this point or she could've considered the probabilities of Internet Dating. I typed into Google: “Find love on the Internet” and got 1,040,000,000 results in .22 seconds.
She’s not alone. Lots of folks are going there. What is the probability that one of them might make a good date, mate, or might have a friend that you could "swap" for? One theory on probability is named for the host of our game show, The Monty Hall Problem.
My favorite moniker for the theory of odds: The Sleeping Beauty Problem.
Consider The Sleeping Beauty Problem. The game is “heads or tails.” Sleeping Beauty agrees to take a potion to find her prince. She will be kissed after the coin is flipped and told how it landed. She won’t remember what she was told when she awoke.
On day one, a coin is flipped, she’s kissed, wakened and told “heads won.” On another day, she’s told “tails won.” And so on.
This probability game examines how Sleeping Beauty will compute the odds of heads or tails without knowing how the coin toss worked any of the times she awoke.
Like me when I entered the Internet dating game ( see my book (Re)Making Love), my Pilates teacher wants the prince to kiss her lips and wake her from the sleep of disillusionment with love.
It happens. And it doesn’t. When it does, it should feel like magic, not like “Let’s Make Deal”, or even worse, like the flip of a coin.
Internet dating operates on the theory that the more you know about the other before you date, the better your odds of finding your prince. We give information in our profiles about who we are and who we’re looking for. That stuff helps.
But if you rely only on what you know about the other, you may make a deal, or worse, you may have flipped a coin. Either way, the magic won’t happen.
The probability theory won’t get her anywhere. I say she should count on knowing herself, on passion and poetry.
I argue that the better you know yourself, the more you understand your own unconscious mind, the more likely that while you date, you will find your prince.
Here is what I learned. The answer to the question, "Where in the world is my prince?" lay inside my own search for self-discovery. I had to answer the tautological question that begins and ends where it starts: Who am I?
The better I came to know myself, the more likely I would find passionate love again.
I argue that has nothing to do with games shows or coin flips.
I don’t mean we should all go into therapy but I don’t dismiss that idea. I mean we need to acknowledge that we love best when we know ourselves, when we stay on the road of self-discovery.
The best connections, the relationships that suffer the slings and arrows of misfortune and that last are based on self-knowledge and empathy. I speak from experience. My marriage broke. I Internet dated. I looked for my prince. But most of the time I looked for myself. I found love and wrote a book to prove it.
Transcendence in love comes hand-in-hand with transformation of the self.
We don’t become the beloved. We don’t own the beloved. The beloved alters us because we feel with the beloved, his or her needs, his or her cares, his or her wants. He or she does the same.
Through empathy with the other, we allow ourselves to become, as psychiatrist Ethel Spector Person says in her book Dreams of Love and Fateful Encounters, “the person we have not yet discovered.”
D.H. Lawrence put it best in his poem “Wedlock”:
And yet all the while you are you, you are not me.
And I am I, I am never you.
How awfully distinct and far off from each other’s being we are!
Yet I am glad.
I am so glad there is always you beyond my scope,
Something that stands over,
Something I shall never be,
That I shall always wonder over, and wait for,
Look for like the breath of life as long as I live,
Still waiting for you, however old you are, and I am,
I shall always wonder over you, and look for you.
And you will always be with me.
I shall never cease to be filled with newness,Having you near me.
So, yes, Internet date. And yes, love is the answer. But don’t forget this: The angel on your shoulder is you.
Note for readers and wanna-be writers: I teach Creative Writing. Free chapters will follow—so you get an idea of how I teach—then you’ll hit a paywall—but I’m less than most others offering help here—and I’ve got teaching skills up the kazoo. Try me! For now, here’s a clip:
And I can help you one-on-one for a small fee, via Zoom, an eight-or-more-"session"-course (each session includes 11 parts) with slides and more experiments than in these chapters in “Write it! How to get started”.
Email me at
for details on how I work.
I taught variations of this course at George Washington University, in the undergraduate and graduate MFA/Ph.D. creative writing program at the University of Missouri and at the Smithsonian's Campus-on-the-Mall.
I’m the author of of Who by Fire a novel, the memoir (Re)Making Love and The Woman Who Never Cooked: Short Stories.
Thanks for reading <Mary’s Newsletter "Only connect ...">! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work. Sundays always free. All early posts FREE, including the first lessons on Write it! How to get started. Cost of a latte for paid lessons. I answer all q’s and comments. If you email me @ firstname.lastname@example.org, I’ll give you a free week of paid posts.
So much truth and wisdom. Thank you for this. I took down my online dating profiles for a wild summer romance with myself. It's been fabulous. I've gotten to know myself better and am confident it will make me more interesting and a better partner. I've also renewed my appreciation for the love of friendship.
I wrote a book about online dating and evaluating my entire life with men in between two cancer treatments. Courting Me(n): Juggling Love, Lust, and Listening Within. I self published it but didn't push to sell it. Then I took it down a few years later because it revealed so much truly personal stuff. I thought I would edit it, but I haven't. The process of writing it, and putting it out into the world, even though I thought I wasn't ready was transformative. My goals for relationships, the authentic truly heart felt goals clarified and got better from that day forward. Did I do therapy? Yes. Did I work on loving myself? Yes. Did I clarify what I really want and need? Yes. My used book still sells for a little less than 4x what I charged for it. In July of 2019 3 copies were selling for $1479 and I have no idea why. Wonderful article. Thank you!